The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has given fans some of the most iconic moments in cinematic history, but one of the most controversial is Thanos’ infamous snap in Avengers: Infinity War. The moment when half of all life in the universe was wiped out shocked audiences worldwide. But as always in the Marvel universe, fans have a way of stirring the pot, and a new fan theory has emerged claiming that the victims of Thanos’ snap were not, in fact, chosen randomly.
According to this latest theory, Thanos had a method behind his madness. Rather than the snap being a random act of destruction, some fans argue that it was all part of a much larger plan. The theory suggests that the victims of the snap were specifically targeted based on certain traits – maybe those who had the potential to oppose his rule or those with unique abilities that could disrupt his plans. If this theory is true, then there’s a hidden logic behind Thanos’ actions, making it more than just a cold, random act.
While the theory sounds intriguing at first glance, here’s why it doesn’t really hold up:
First of all, Thanos himself repeatedly stated that his actions were meant to be impartial and “random.” If he had selected individuals based on their abilities or importance, he would have taken a much more strategic approach, and we would have seen patterns in the people who disappeared. Instead, we saw a variety of characters from all walks of life and across multiple galaxies, including heroes, civilians, and even secondary characters.
Another reason this theory falls short is the emotional impact the snap had on the remaining Avengers. If Thanos had been selective, it could have made it harder for the surviving heroes to form an emotional bond over the event, as they might have seen their losses as inevitable or justified. The randomness of the snap, however, heightened the emotional stakes – the sense that anyone could go at any moment, regardless of their importance, is what made the snap so tragic.
It’s also important to note that Thanos’ main goal was always to “balance” the universe by eliminating half of all life – not specifically targeting individuals with certain traits. His belief was that wiping out random individuals would restore balance to a universe overpopulated and suffering from resource scarcity. While his execution of this plan was flawed and catastrophic, the randomness actually helped drive home the gravity of his decision.
In conclusion, while fan theories are often fun and offer exciting new ways to look at beloved stories, this one doesn’t quite fit with the established logic of the MCU. Thanos’ snap wasn’t some kind of calculated move to rid the universe of specific threats—it was, as he stated, random, and it was meant to be a cold, indifferent solution to an existential problem. Ultimately, the randomness of the snap is what made it so devastating for the characters we love.