Carrie Underwood just dropped a bombshell about her biggest American Idol regret—and it’s tied to none other than 2021 winner Chayce Beckham! As the country superstar hints at a past mistake, fans are buzzing over Beckham’s unexpected return to the show. Here’s the tea you can’t miss.
“I Wish I Spoke Up Sooner”: Carrie’s Candid Regret
During a recent podcast interview, Underwood—Idol’s 2005 champ—got real about a decision that’s haunted her for years. Though not a full-time judge, Carrie guest-mentored during Beckham’s season and admits she held back praise early on. “Chayce had this raw, gritty magic,” she shared. “But I second-guessed pushing harder for him. Now, seeing his success? I wish I’d screamed his name from day one.”
The confession shocked fans, especially since Beckham, 24, dominated his season with his soulful rasp and heartfelt originals like 23.
Chayce Beckham’s Triumphant Comeback
Just days after Carrie’s reveal, American Idol announced Beckham will return as a guest mentor for Season 22’s Hollywood Week—and perform his new single! Since winning, the California native’s career has skyrocketed: his debut album hit No. 1 on iTunes, and he’s racked up 50+ million streams. “Coming back feels surreal,” Beckham posted. “Ready to pay it forward!”
Fan Frenzy Erupts
Social media exploded with reactions. One fan tweeted, “Carrie admitting she underrated Chayce? Growth!” Another gushed, “CHAYCE’S MENTOR ERA IS HERE—SAVE THE TEARS FOR HIS PERFORMANCE.”
What’s Next for Idol?
With Beckham’s comeback and judges Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie teasing “unforgettable twists,” Season 22 is already heating up. Will Carrie make a guest appearance to redeem her regret? Producers are staying mum… but we’re betting on drama!